is the huge Musk Cat in PS4...Myau?

[Siren]

That line "passed down for generations" should be payed attention to, especially since the claw itself was Myau's. This gives enough contectual information to piece together that the Old Man is Myau's offspring. It's not hard to fathom that the Nut of Laerma might have some lasting growth effects on his offspring.<p>Alot of the time, Phans jump to conclusions without paying careful attention to contectual information. For example, we would never have the terrible Noah isn't Lutz theory if Mike Ripplinger had paid attention to the context the story was presented in.

[Kars!]

<blockquote><i>Originally posted by Siren</i><p>That line "passed down for generations" </blockquote><p>good point

[Siren]

Benoit made it before myself...

[Benoit]

Even Noah, who was a special Esper, in a sense, didn't survive 2000 years. So why would Myau?

[ThePeaGuy]

<blockquote><i>Originally posted by Benoit</i><p>Even Noah, who was a special Esper, in a sense, didn't survive 2000 years. So why would Myau?<br></blockquote><p>Noah's body survived for a millenia by cryogenic treatments but lost its affect on Noah after Mother Brain was destroyed, so then he passed on his will to Espers of great potential for five generations.<p>Myau, in a sense, lived on after PS1 because it seems that the Musk Cats are the only species that can pass on their memories to future generations.

[Benoit]

But there still needed to be a Lutz, so why wouldn't he have lived on if he wanted? I think he just couldn't live any longer.<br><p>[size=small][Edit by Benoit on [TIME]1111958564[/TIME]][/size]

[ThePeaGuy]

<blockquote><i>Originally posted by Benoit</i><p>But there still needed to be a Lutz, so why wouldn't he have lived on if he wanted? I think he just couldn't live any longer.<br></blockquote><p>This is purely conjecture, but I think that when Rune said that Lutz/Noah died five generations ago (probably 1000 years.), Lutz probably fused his spirit into the sword Elsydeon/Nei Sword in order to empower it, but he kept his memory intact inside the Telepathy Ball, so that the chosen Espers can carry on his existence through their bodies.<br><p>[size=small][Edit by ThePeaGuy on [TIME]1110742408[/TIME]][/size]

[Malakai]

I've always wondered about the Lutz's between Lutz I and Rune Walsh. I mean, even though the other three didn't take part in fighting against DF or the PD they still carried the Mantle. So what became of them? What were their lives like? What were their names?

[Gipper]

Although it is my belief that the giant kitty is NOT Myau, at best any evidence one way or the other is circumstancial. There is nothing conclusive. The best we can hope for is that someone can find a way to jump into video games, and take a DNA sample of both of them and compare it.

[Lassic's Chllun]

<blockquote>I have a feeling that this is the not first time we've met...<br>-Old Man</blockquote> <p>So what about that? It must mean something.

[Shell Presto]

<blockquote><i>Originally posted by Benoit</i><p>But there still needed to be a Lutz, so why wouldn't he have lived on if he wanted? I think he just couldn't live any longer.<br></blockquote><p>I think we are forgetting that Lutz was a human being, not just some great esper. I think he could have lived on if he wanted to, but he would rather pass his memories on. I mean, really, his friends died 1,000 years ago, he had the horrible job of sending protectors on a mission of their doom, and without a telepathy ball he couldn't risk death, so he couldn't fight with them. <p>So he made a telepathy ball, maybe figuring he could start fighting biomonsters for the good of humanity once again while training espers, and then he died a peaceful death. <br>

[Lord Khyron]

I've proved in another post a year ago that Musk Cats have a collective intelligence and share memories.<p>Hence the Old Man's statement.

[Lassic's Chllun]

Dammit...that would have been a nice link, too...oh, well. *kicks Old Man* YOU IMPOSTER!