Which NPC Would You Like To Be Able To Have In Your Party?

[Kalisiin]

For me,

PS2 - I'll take Tyler

PS3 I'll take Lune

I do not think there are any in PS1 or PS4, really.

Now, in PS2, the only non-player characters I can think of would be Darum, Tiem, Tyler, and Lutz

In PS3, I don't count the "old" characters, like Old Rhys, etc...so your choices in PS3 are
Maia, Lune, and Alair

I just think Lune would really kick some azz in PS3...and Tyler would make things very interesting in PS2, I've written about this elsewhere...I really think Tyler should have joined your party in PS2. It would have made a far more interesting story, and a better storyline, generally. Plus, it would be a way to replace Nei, who you lose...so you'd have eight characters to pick your party from.

Tyler, being a Pirate, would, I believe have some very good strong attacks, and a few good techniques, too. He probably would not be much of a healer.

Even if Tyler didn't directly join your party...it would have been much cooler, in the storyline....if Tyler let you use his ship after he rescued you from Gaila...instead of this sudden appearance of a spaceship at the tower on Mota. And he could pilot the ship for you, taking you where you wanted to go, Dezo or Mota...and you could even talk to him at times to get more information about Mother Brain.

Tyler would be a very fun addition to PS2.

[DarkMyau]

PS1: A motavian or Dezorian would have been fun.

PS2: NeiFirst or one of the Espers from the Esper Mansion. I see your point with Tyler. One of the Musk Cats running around Skure spaceport would have been fun too.

PS3: A bio Monster or two. You are a Layan 2nd and 3rd generation.

PS4: A Musk Cat character. Not a Numan, a Musk Cat.

[Brian]

PS1: I would have liked to have seen a playable hapsby that can use guns, perhaps similar to demi, although the game difficulty would need to be increased to rebalance it.

PS2: an active Lutz that joins the party and has a wide variety of techniques.

PS3: not so much playable characters but maybe a subquest involving miuen and siren exploring glimpses of their past and how they came to be in the situations you find them.